News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Feedlot proposal rejected 

Feedlot proposal rejected

06 Jan, 2009 08:28 AM
A planning permit for a proposed lamb feedlot at Crowlands has been rejected by Pyrenees Shire Council.

Crowlands farmer Perry Richards lodged an application with Pyrenees Shire Council on June 30 last year to develop the land, located on Glendu Road, into a feedlot.

The application outlined that around 10,000 lot-fed lambs would be kept on the site, which is located in a gully on the Glendu creek line.

Effluent runoff from the pens would be captured within two holding ponds which were to be built within the waterway.

The application came before council at its December meeting and was rejected on the grounds that the location chosen for the feedlot and its associated effluent treatment ponds would endanger nearby waterways.

In considering the application, council declared the proposal failed to meet five clauses within the Pyrenees Planning Scheme.

Mr Richards said the outcome was disappointing.

``The whole thing was tied up between Wimmera CMA and GWMWater for almost a year,'' Mr Richards said.

``Neither one would accept responsibility.''

Mr Richards said the Wimmera Catchment Management Authority told him in the early stages of planning the feedlot that the development did not fall under their responsibility and directed him to GWMWater.

``GWMWater gave us a letter saying they had no objections to us putting in two dams in the gully to catch the (effluent) runoff,'' Mr Richards said.

With this in mind, consultants drafted up plans, which were then submitted to Pyrenees Shire Council.

The application received three objections; two from neighbouring properties and one from the Wimmera CMA.

Mr Richards said council advised him to identify another site on the property which might be suitable for the proposed feedlot.

``I can identify another site but they can still knock me back,'' Mr Richards said.

``I could take them to VCAT and contest it but that's only going to drag the whole process out.''

Mr Richards estimated he has already spent around $130,000 on the feedlot development, injecting $80,000 into the site itself and spending around $50,000 on consultants and other associated costs.

On top of the money he has invested in the development, Mr Richards believes there is millions of dollars at stake for the region as a whole.

``I've brought a thousand tonne of hay locally which has put $200,000 into local farmers' pockets,'' Mr Richards said.

In addition, he has purchased 3500 tonne of barley, employs four people full-time and contracts local transport companies to transport grain in and take stock out of the feedlot.

``They're all in jeopardy of losing their jobs,'' Mr Richards said.

Andrew Leach, director of assets and development at Pyrenees Shire Council, said council voted against the application in its current form because of the potential for waste from the effluent storage ponds to enter nearby properties and the Glendu Creek.

``The potential for waste and nutrients to enter adjoining waterways is considered to be high and is considered to pose an unacceptable environmental risk to adjoining waterways and beneficial users,'' Mr Leach said.

``The Wimmera CMA have also objected to the siting of the effluent storage ponds within a declared waterway.

``The site chosen for the feedlot pens also poses potential environmental risks in the management of run-off and erosion, due to the pen slopes exceeding the 10 per cent and the inability for sedimentation ponds to be incorporated into the effluent treatment area.''

Mr Leach said Mr Perry can continue to liaise with council planning staff to work through the areas of the permit which are of concern, such as the location of the effluent storage ponds and feedlot pens, so another submission can be made to council.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


No comments yet. Be the first to comment below.

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

Classifieds promo
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...